I have this book and am in the process of going over it, may do a review of it eventually.
Short take from my first quick view, the book is a congregation of public web pages, in print form. So far I have not come across anything unique to the book, and most passages that I have searched for turn out to be word for word, cut and paste, from various web sites. Most often without crediting the web site.
T!
(edit, my review of this book below)
"Secret Spy Radio Stations" Series 1, by Ronald Milione.
This is a book I have been looking forward to since I first heard it was in work. Spy Numbers stations have been a secondary listening hobby of mine since I first heard such broadcasts in the late 1960's. Books on the subject are few and far between, and so I look forward to any new non-fiction publications related to Spy Numbers.
I ordered this book as soon as I was aware it was available, and had it in hand 2 days later. I was especially jazzed when I saw the "Series 1" in the title, hopeful that this was the first installment in a series of books on the subject.
To call the book a disappointment is to be kind. It has much outdated and incorrect information, and it appears to be, in large part, copy / paste from various web sites and prior publications.
The book is a large paperback, about 8.5" by 11", and with roughly 220 pages of large type text, single picture per page illustrations, and various tables / charts. I say roughly 220 pages because there is not a single page number in the entire book, so I have no idea how many pages it really is.
There is also no Table of Contents and no Index.
The first page is titled "Why this book series? Here is why...." and then launches directly into the body of Simon Mason's publication "Secret Signals - The Euronumbers Mystery" (
https://labyrinth13.com/Secret%20Signals.pdf ), minus the original title or author. The first 12 pages of the book are word-for-word identical to the first 6 pages of Simons publication. And no indication, at all, in those pages, as to the source. There is no acknowledgment of Simons work until near the very end of the book, when it generically lists Simons publication as a source, with no definition of what parts of this book were related to Simons work.
The next 5 pages start with a two sentence paragraph which appears to be original text, and then launches into a word-for-word cut and paste from the Wikipedia entry on the Warrenton Training Center. Several pictures are interspersed with the Wiki text that were not originally part of the Wiki entry. The next several pages are primarily word-for-word copies from the Wiki entry on the Voice of Korea, although that segment does appear to contain several paragraphs of original text, interspersed with the Wiki copy.
Aside from added pictures, mostly from Google Earth, in the first 30 pages of the book there are less than 2 pages of original text, the rest is direct copy and paste, without cite, from sources such as Simon Masons "Euronumbers Mystery" paper, or from something like Wikipedia. This is a theme that is repeated throughout the book, copy some source word-for-word, do not cite the original source, throw in a sentence or paragraph here and there with original text, and add some pictures from public sources.
Because so much of the book is copy / pasted from other sources, without editing, it often contains information that is incorrect today. For example, it discusses numbers stations in the present tense, and calls them "active", despite the fact that particularly station may not have been active for years. It was when the copied paper or web site was published, but there appears to have been no effort to fact check any of the information presented.
For example, the section on the Yosemite Sam oddity is written in the present tense, the book says "it transmits on four frequencies:" and then lists the Sam freqs. For those not aware, Yosemite Sam was an oddity station that was active in 2004 and 2005, and the text in the book comes from an old write-up on the web, found here
http://www.spynumbers.com/YosemiteSam.html The books entry on this station is word-for-word from that web page, including the colored text (light gray in the book) for the hypertext link to the .wav sound sample.
In one of the few more-or-less well cited entries in the book the author copied, word-for-word, the description text from a YouTube video of the Chinese Robot, VC01. Including the YT channel disclaimer "Disclaimer: Many of the radio reception recordings on this Youtube channel pertain to unusual, uncommon, unknown, or mystery signals that might be found on radio, both shortwave and VHF/UHF. Among the subjects covered are numbers stations, utility stations, military transmissions (both in the clear and encrypted / encoded), aviation, maritime, ham radio, CB radio, radars, ionosodes, propagation beacons, ditters, dashers, whistlers, and just about anything else that might transmit, in any mode, USB, LSB, CW, Morse Code, FM, AM,FMCW, LFMCW, etc. Think of it as SIGINT (signals intelligence) / COMINT (communications intelligence) / ELINT (electronic intelligence) lite, the hobby version. All the recordings are made by me, most often at my home. Although there are a few mysterious things to be found here, you will not find anything paranormal, extraterrestrial, spiritual, or mystic. However, everyone can have their own interpretations of the sounds heard, make of it what you will."
Not sure what all that extra text has to do with VC01, or why it would be valuable in the context of this book.
The author uses ENGIMA IDs, such as E05, V07, V15, etc, as well as common nicknames, "Cynthia", "The Cuban Babbler", etc. But never explains how such names or designations came to be, or, in the case of the IDs, what they mean. Many of the basic concepts of the hobby are missing or glossed over.
All-in-all, the book "Secret Spy Radio Stations", by Ronald Milione, is a disappointment, at best. It rambles, the format shifts around section to section, and there is no new or interesting data that cannot be found with a Google search. Such a paper presented in highschool would garner a failing mark based on the blatant plagiarism alone. This book is little more than a collection of web pages, bound and printed. Interesting web pages, to be sure, but nothing more.
Show Posts
The one marked in green sounds very similar to your recording.