I'm commenting because this made me think of a ham in Finland named Greg White, whom I'm pretty sure is Australian by birth and had a decent ham radio & shortwave channel on youtube. A couple of months ago he posted some crazy video claiming that ham radio wasn't of any effectiveness in times of emergency using the most hackneyed reasoning (basically since few people die in forest fires annually, there's no real need for hams - it was something along those lines). I know from interactions I had with him on Facebook that he had zero tolerance for mild disagreement, so he must have gotten a ton of blowback for that video. He deleted his channel so I can't link back for everyone to see how ridiculous it was, but that kind of reaction is what I'd expect based on the reaction he was inviting with such an absurd argument.