218
« on: January 24, 2020, 1243 UTC »
Don’t get me wrong - I think what K1JT has done with weak signal detection is amazing. His work with EME software has made moonbounce possible for small footprint stations. Ditto his meteor scatter SW.
I have no problem with his weak signal algorithms. My problem has been with automation of the QSO process. His implementation has the operators involvement being nothing more than clicking a button to log the QSO...and modified code is available that allows you to run in full robot mode. I saw one of Joe Taylor’s presentations where he had a slide of suspected “robot” stations (based upon the fact that they ran 24/7), and I have seen the robot SW for sale on eBay. The days of fully automated stations working each other have already started.
If you ever find a first edition (circa 1983) copy of W9KNI’s book “The Complete DXer”, it is worth reading. He has stories in it of tuning through the bands searching for DX, and puzzling out the rare and not so rare stuff. It took some skill to find and work a rare one back then, and it was very rewarding when you were successful. Today, with DX spotting networks, etc it is much more like shooting fish in a barrel. Now full automation has removed the last vestige of necessary operator skill.
Maybe this explains some of the renewed interest in learning CW. Maybe these are operators that are seeking some of the satisfaction you find in doing something difficult and succeeding...
Its like I said before: People don’t value things that come too easily.